Serving Draper, UT and nearby towns
Open 24/7 · (385) 488-1892
Gloved hands adjusting the fill valve inside a toilet tank
Home / Blog / Toilet Keeps Running in Draper, UT?

Toilet Keeps Running in Draper, UT?

Nearly every running toilet comes down to one of three parts. A ten-minute test tells you which.

Talk to a plumber
(385) 488-1892
Call Now

Lift the tank lid and look. If water is flowing over the top of the overflow tube, the fill valve or float is set too high. If the water level is fine but the toilet refills on its own every few minutes, the flapper is leaking. Both fixes use cheap parts. If you would rather have it done, (385) 488-1892 reaches our line any hour, and most toilet repairs finish in one visit.

Three parts, three symptoms

Match the symptom to the part
What you noticePart at faultWhy it happens
Water trickles into the bowl, toilet refills now and thenFlapperThe rubber seal has warped or has mineral buildup and no longer seals
Water runs over the overflow tubeFill valve or floatThe float is set too high or the valve will not shut off
A hissing sound and slow refillFill valveDebris or wear in the valve
Handle must be held down to stop the flushChain or handleThe chain is too short or too long and hangs up the flapper
Tank sweats and drips on the floorCondensation or a cracked tankCold water meets warm humid air

The food coloring test

Add color

Put a few drops of food coloring in the tank. Do not flush.

Wait fifteen minutes

Leave the toilet alone.

Check the bowl

Color in the bowl means the flapper is leaking. No color means the leak is somewhere else, or the fill valve is the problem.

Check the water level

It should sit about an inch below the top of the overflow tube. Higher is a fill valve or float problem.

Fixing a flapper

Close the supply valve behind the toilet and flush to empty the tank. Unhook the flapper from the overflow tube ears and the chain. Take the old flapper to a hardware store and match it. Seat the new one, set the chain with about a half-inch of slack and open the valve. Flush and watch. A new flapper often fixes the problem for years.

Draper note: why parts wear out early

Draper City's 2022 water quality report lists total hardness from 16 to 357 mg/L, and the high end counts as very hard on the USGS scale. Hard water leaves mineral film on rubber seals and in the fill valve, which makes them stiff and leaky. A toilet in a very hard water area may need a new flapper every few years instead of every decade.

The Utah Division of Water Resources describes Draper City service as generally west of I-15 and south of 14600 S, and WaterPro as east of I-15 and north of 14600 S. Check which one is on your bill, then ask that utility about local hardness if you want to plan maintenance.

Fixing a fill valve

Fill valves wear out and clog with debris. Replacement is a standard task: shut off the supply, empty the tank, disconnect the supply line, unscrew the old valve nut under the tank and install the new valve at the right height. Flush the supply line before reconnecting, to clear grit. Set the float height according to the instructions and check for leaks.

If you are uncomfortable working with the supply line or the tank bolts, a plumber can handle it. See toilet repair for what a visit includes. If the toilet also clogs often, the problem may be farther down, and drain cleaning can tell whether the line is the cause.

Toilet still running?

Call and we will fix the part and test the flush on the same visit.

Call (385) 488-1892

What a running toilet costs you

A silent leak can waste a lot of water every day, and it will show up on your bill. Draper reports that about 63% of its water demand is outdoor use, so an indoor leak can hide in summer numbers. A winter bill is a cleaner place to spot it. If your meter moves with everything off, see leak detection.

When the fix is not a part

Call a plumber if you notice

  • Water on the floor around the base of the toilet.
  • A toilet that rocks when you sit.
  • A crack in the bowl or tank.
  • A supply valve that will not close or leaks.
  • A toilet that backs up when other fixtures drain.
  • A leak that returns after you replaced parts.

A toilet that rocks has a loose flange or a failed wax ring, which can leak into the floor. A supply valve that will not close is a plumbing repair of its own, and it is better done before you need to shut off water in an emergency.

Quick adjustments before replacing anything

Sometimes nothing is broken, only out of adjustment. Check that the chain from the handle to the flapper has a half inch of slack. A chain that is too tight holds the flapper open a crack, and a chain that is too long can tangle under it.

Look at the float, too. On a ball float, bend the arm gently down. On a cup float, slide the clip down the rod. Flush and watch the water level settle an inch below the overflow tube.

Write down the make and model printed inside the tank or on the lid before you shop. It saves a second trip.

Choosing replacement parts

Match the flapper size

Two-inch and three-inch flush valves need different flappers. Measure the opening.

Use a quality fill valve

Cheap valves wear fast. Pick one with a replaceable cartridge.

Replace the supply line

Braided lines age. Replace a line that is more than ten years old.

Consider a new toilet

A cracked tank or a decades-old model that uses far more water may be cheaper to replace than to keep repairing.

Sources and standards behind this page

Flapper and fill valve repairs are routine field practice, and toilet installation follows the International Plumbing Code (IPC) as amended by the Utah State Construction Code in Utah Code Title 15A. Hardness figures come from Draper City's 2022 water quality report.

Straight Answers

A leaking flapper lets water seep into the bowl, and the fill valve opens to refill the tank. It is the most common cause.

Add food coloring to the tank and wait fifteen minutes without flushing. Color in the bowl means the flapper leaks.

Yes. Minerals build on seals and in valves. Draper City reports total hardness up to 357 mg/L at some sources.

It can waste a lot over a day, depending on the leak. It shows up on the water bill.

Worn parts usually are not. A sudden overflow causing water damage may be covered, so ask your agent.

Yes. Call (385) 488-1892 any hour. Close the supply valve behind the toilet while you wait.

Need A Plumber Right Now?

Call (385) 488-1892. A dispatcher answers 24 hours a day.

☎ Call (385) 488-1892

Our Draper, UT Service Area

Dispatch runs from Draper and covers Draper, Riverton, Sandy, South Jordan and Herriman along the south end of the Salt Lake Valley. Call (385) 488-1892 any hour to confirm your address is in range.

☎ Call (385) 488-1892 · 24/7